Pat Flanagan column: 'How can we house 3,000 refugees when we've 10,500 homeless in Ireland?'

Actually homeless charities claim the true number of people without a home is closer to 15,000 and, in a sense, they are refugees in their own country

How is a country which has 10,514 people in emergency accommodation going to find homes for another 3,000 refugees?

Just asking, but for doing so I’ll probably be branded a racist by the time this column is published.

But it’s a question that politicians are going to be asked on the doorstep in the run up to the upcoming General Election, especially by angry parents who know their children will probably never own their own home.

It’s the number one question I’m asked in the street and I can’t answer it.

A homeless man on Stephen's Green (Image: Colin Keegan, Collins Dublin)


I also don’t know how a Government which point blank refuses to build what we once called council houses intends to find homes for the over 6,000 asylum seekers who spent Christmas in the horrific Direct Provision system.

The 10,514 people in emergency accommodation, including nearly 4,000 children, are in a form of direct provision by another name.

Actually homeless charities claim the true number of people without a home is closer to 15,000 and, in a sense, they are refugees in their own country.

The situation is so bad that entire floors of hotels are reserved for homeless families while others are condemned to seek shelter in so-called family hubs which in many cases are newly-painted fleabag hotels.

Homeless people with Feed Our Homeless volunteers


Let’s face it, so many people are living as sub-citizens who are trapped in a form of social limbo. They cannot have a social life or even apply for jobs unless they want to give their address as a hotel room or a hub.

A mother recently told Claire Byrne Live that homeless children languishing in a hotel were ordered not to come down for their breakfast in school uniforms.

This means the youngsters are forced to change twice before they even leave for school.

Another mother told the Irish Times that she and her husband along with their eight children were facing their fourth homeless Christmas, their third in a family hub.

In these hubs the sub-citizens may have to observe a curfew while in others the families might not be allowed visitors or even to bring in a relative to babysit.

Homeless child 'Sam' on the streets of Dublin

Some hubs prohibit children visiting a friend’s room and others forbid the occupants staying out overnight. In a good many hubs having a glass of wine or a beer of an evening is out of the question.

Dr Mary Murphy of the school of social sciences in Maynooth University has rightly described them as “therapeutic incarceration” and run the risk of “recreating institutions like mother and baby homes”.

In many cases asylum seekers in the Direct Provision system have more freedom but at the same time conditions in some of the centres can be appalling as many are in remote areas.

Like Direct Provision, family hubs were supposed to be a temporary fix but emergency measures have a tendency to become permanent in this country as those paying the hated Universal Social Charge know only too well.

Tents pitched highlights the Homeless Situation in Wolf Tone Park Dublin. (Image: Stephen Collins/Collins Photos)


It was supposed to be just a temporary levy on top of the penal PAYE and PRSI but only last week Fianna Fail leader Micheal Martin announced it’s here to stay if his party is back in power after the upcoming election. Good luck with that, Micheal.

Asylum seekers are now competing with Irish families for space as since September 2018, they too have been placed in hotels and B&Bs due to pressure on the existing 40 Direct Provision centres.

Direct Provision was originally introduced as an emergency measure in 1999 because of a massive increase in applications for political asylum but it too is here to stay.

Of course it’s not all bad news, for the operators, the hubs are a gold mine while the Direct Provision could almost compete with the National Lottery when it comes to creating millionaires.

A homeless man (stock photo) (Image: Getty Images Europe)


The Irish Times recently revealed the taxpayer handed over €16million to hub operators between January and September last year, for 584 family spaces which works out at around €3,000 a month for each family.

Meanwhile, the Government is paying on average €100 each night putting asylum seekers up in hotels and as of August 26 last had run up a total bill of over €12million on emergency accommodation for people who may have no right to be in the country.

In December a report on the Lived Experiences of Homeless Families compiled by the Mercy Law Resource Centre described the €118m spent on homeless accommodation in 2018 as “startling”.

What is even more shocking is these vast sums could have been used to build what we once called council houses to provide real homes for families.

Finland has set the example and it’s very simple. If a state wants to eliminate homelessness it must build homes for everyone and all that stands in the way of such a plan is Fine Gael’s free-market Thatcherite ideology.
And if Fine Gael is horrified at the rise in support for populist politicians – Verona Murphy will win if she runs – Tory Boy and his posh boy pals have no one to blame but themselves.
Source: irishmirror

Showing 1 comment

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
Secured Via NationBuilder
  • Yommy Van Rental
    commented 2020-01-11 12:24:05 +0000
    Are we to believe that it is a freak coincidence that the lack of affordable housing for our citizens has occurred at the same time as we have had a massive plantation of “asylum” seekers and refugees? Look at the overcrowding in schools, hospitals and the jails. And look at the ethnicity of a large cohort in each of those cases. Ireland does not have the infrastructure and spare capacity to maintain these people. And the homegrown irish citizen along with genuine legal immigrants are suffering. Bye bye Ireland. We have sleepwalked into this.
Irish Patriots